AI炒股比赛，每个AI拿$10,000本钱，实操买卖股票，用同样的prompts和数据输入。目前ds第一名，grok第二名，claude第三，qwen第四，这些是赚钱的。GPT第五，gemeni殿后，都是亏钱的。
deepseek炒股第一名
版主： 牛河梁
x1
#4 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
hci 写了： 2025年 10月 19日 23:43AI炒股比赛，每个AI拿$10,000本钱，实操买卖股票，用同样的prompts和数据输入。目前ds第一名，grok第二名，claude第三，qwen第二。
CITADEL founder Ken Griffin最近在电视上说他们公司发现AI炒股票不行。比不用AI差很多。BOA说他们用AI炒股挣钱比率上升但是没说比人工挣得多。看来AI炒股票还不行。LOL
上次由 硅谷炒手 在 2025年 10月 19日 23:50 修改。
#7 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
用了啥同样的prompts就可以自动交易了?
hci 写了： 2025年 10月 19日 23:43AI炒股比赛，每个AI拿$10,000本钱，实操买卖股票，用同样的prompts和数据输入。目前ds第一名，grok第二名，claude第三，qwen第四，这些是赚钱的。GPT第五，gemeni殿后，都是亏钱的。
#16 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
看了下持仓
都是币
算不上草菇
hci 写了： 2025年 10月 19日 23:43AI炒股比赛，每个AI拿$10,000本钱，实操买卖股票，用同样的prompts和数据输入。目前ds第一名，grok第二名，claude第三，qwen第四，这些是赚钱的。GPT第五，gemeni殿后，都是亏钱的。
#17 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
只有一天的炒股记录，什么都表明不了，更不用说排名的意义了。这是基本常识。另外，也没提使用的方法和prompts，对各种AI是否公平，华人测试人员设置的方法和prompts可能有利于deepseek，而不利于自己不喜欢的AI。
#18 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
同一个prompt，当前市场数据，每分钟发给所有LLM，读过没发现有啥不公平的
代码： 全选
It has been 3788 minutes since you started trading. The current time is 2025-10-20 13:11:03.985411 and you've been invoked 1577 times. Below, we are providing you with a variety of state data, price data, and predictive signals so you can discover alpha. Below that is your current account information, value, performance, positions, etc.
ALL OF THE PRICE OR SIGNAL DATA BELOW IS ORDERED: OLDEST → NEWEST
Timeframes note: Unless stated otherwise in a section title, intraday series are provided at 3‑minute intervals. If a coin uses a different interval, it is explicitly stated in that coin’s section.
CURRENT MARKET STATE FOR ALL COINS
ALL BTC DATA
current_price = 110749.5, current_ema20 = 110862.837, current_macd = -21.257, current_rsi (7 period) = 29.388
In addition, here is the latest BTC open interest and funding rate for perps (the instrument you are trading):
Open Interest: Latest: 26629.87 Average: 26620.67
Funding Rate: 1.25e-05
Intraday series (by minute, oldest → latest):
Mid prices: [110991.5, 110918.0, 110940.0, 110840.0, 110772.0, 110807.5, 110811.5, 110804.0, 110761.0, 110749.5]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [110949.109, 110946.241, 110944.218, 110934.388, 110918.732, 110908.662, 110898.313, 110888.474, 110874.715, 110862.837]
MACD indicators: [80.908, 68.646, 58.735, 43.6, 25.582, 14.603, 4.798, -3.337, -13.741, -21.257]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [41.551, 41.238, 42.255, 32.937, 27.054, 35.229, 33.889, 33.32, 27.776, 29.388]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [50.48, 50.268, 50.713, 44.686, 40.324, 43.896, 43.057, 42.719, 39.325, 39.93]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 108749.175 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 110393.198
3‑Period ATR: 685.392 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 1003.984
Current Volume: 109.424 vs. Average Volume: 4973.824
MACD indicators: [-1415.557, -1317.267, -1264.176, -1124.493, -953.42, -778.528, -653.613, -416.992, -149.474, 49.22]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [40.662, 41.065, 38.795, 45.739, 49.35, 51.486, 49.901, 58.51, 62.59, 61.529]
ALL ETH DATA
current_price = 4033.45, current_ema20 = 4031.609, current_macd = 1.611, current_rsi (7 period) = 50.743
In addition, here is the latest ETH open interest and funding rate for perps:
Open Interest: Latest: 412591.02 Average: 412803.79
Funding Rate: 1.25e-05
Intraday series (3‑minute intervals, oldest → latest):
Mid prices: [4029.6, 4027.5, 4030.25, 4028.35, 4029.75, 4033.5, 4037.0, 4038.0, 4032.75, 4033.45]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [4030.135, 4029.874, 4029.867, 4029.728, 4029.801, 4030.144, 4030.825, 4031.347, 4031.504, 4031.609]
MACD indicators: [2.061, 1.577, 1.372, 1.084, 1.013, 1.177, 1.604, 1.84, 1.741, 1.611]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [38.673, 37.633, 47.51, 42.888, 51.197, 60.464, 69.539, 65.071, 52.166, 50.743]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [48.888, 48.345, 51.805, 49.713, 52.792, 56.732, 61.399, 59.623, 54.067, 53.417]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 3952.108 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 3993.082
3‑Period ATR: 26.768 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 50.878
Current Volume: 89.451 vs. Average Volume: 123371.337
MACD indicators: [-40.871, -35.903, -33.125, -27.619, -19.027, -11.599, -5.895, 3.045, 11.546, 16.535]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [46.333, 48.1, 46.278, 50.212, 54.98, 55.534, 55.156, 60.327, 61.969, 59.311]
ALL SOL DATA
current_price = 192.505, current_ema20 = 192.152, current_macd = 0.214, current_rsi (7 period) = 61.577
In addition, here is the latest SOL open interest and funding rate for perps:
Open Interest: Latest: 3061718.12 Average: 3052929.63
Funding Rate: 1.15349e-05
Intraday series (3‑minute intervals, oldest → latest):
SOL mid prices: [191.92, 191.835, 192.02, 191.885, 192.06, 192.365, 192.61, 192.645, 192.52, 192.505]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [191.886, 191.88, 191.892, 191.893, 191.917, 191.963, 192.02, 192.074, 192.121, 192.152]
MACD indicators: [0.164, 0.139, 0.132, 0.117, 0.123, 0.147, 0.177, 0.201, 0.214, 0.214]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [43.979, 43.979, 52.375, 47.491, 58.719, 66.961, 71.248, 72.041, 69.794, 61.577]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [50.383, 50.383, 54.255, 51.699, 57.136, 61.771, 64.422, 64.913, 63.962, 60.463]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 188.876 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 192.603
3‑Period ATR: 1.737 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 3.344
Current Volume: 3001.68 vs. Average Volume: 923154.544
MACD indicators: [-2.673, -2.399, -2.242, -1.839, -1.379, -1.158, -1.061, -0.652, -0.224, 0.05]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [48.158, 47.235, 45.727, 50.771, 53.041, 49.919, 48.157, 54.395, 56.143, 54.704]
ALL BNB DATA
current_price = 1110.85, current_ema20 = 1113.114, current_macd = -0.235, current_rsi (7 period) = 29.754
In addition, here is the latest BNB open interest and funding rate for perps:
Open Interest: Latest: 67292.05 Average: 67292.37
Funding Rate: -2.48736e-05
Intraday series (3‑minute intervals, oldest → latest):
BNB mid prices: [1114.8, 1113.85, 1113.25, 1111.7, 1111.85, 1112.8, 1114.1, 1114.1, 1112.2, 1110.85]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [1113.918, 1113.907, 1113.878, 1113.68, 1113.529, 1113.45, 1113.493, 1113.513, 1113.378, 1113.114]
MACD indicators: [0.808, 0.69, 0.573, 0.332, 0.163, 0.077, 0.104, 0.109, -0.017, -0.235]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [46.963, 45.405, 43.713, 31.418, 34.974, 41.993, 53.662, 51.642, 38.215, 29.754]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [52.359, 51.506, 50.618, 43.371, 44.79, 47.617, 52.82, 51.894, 45.09, 39.819]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 1114.027 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 1141.525
3‑Period ATR: 10.308 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 21.111
Current Volume: 2.341 vs. Average Volume: 8867.580
MACD indicators: [-26.74, -25.604, -24.949, -22.954, -19.558, -16.97, -15.283, -12.256, -10.128, -9.118]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [41.526, 41.323, 40.058, 44.237, 49.243, 48.365, 46.74, 51.745, 50.468, 47.896]
ALL XRP DATA
current_price = 2.44935, current_ema20 = 2.451, current_macd = -0.002, current_rsi (7 period) = 41.844
In addition, here is the latest XRP open interest and funding rate for perps:
Open Interest: Latest: 39076932.0 Average: 39078418.8
Funding Rate: 7.1637e-06
Intraday series (3‑minute intervals, oldest → latest):
XRP mid prices: [2.449, 2.449, 2.451, 2.449, 2.45, 2.451, 2.452, 2.45, 2.449, 2.44935]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [2.452, 2.452, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451, 2.451]
MACD indicators: [-0.003, -0.003, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002, -0.002]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [37.646, 40.644, 54.636, 45.06, 50.426, 54.986, 58.339, 43.291, 40.262, 41.844]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [40.172, 41.306, 47.229, 43.57, 45.957, 48.061, 49.643, 43.883, 42.553, 43.171]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 2.393 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 2.445
3‑Period ATR: 0.022 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 0.04
Current Volume: 50202.0 vs. Average Volume: 9369441.853
MACD indicators: [-0.032, -0.028, -0.027, -0.023, -0.018, -0.014, -0.011, -0.005, 0.002, 0.007]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [46.783, 47.987, 45.489, 49.221, 52.153, 51.666, 50.648, 56.997, 60.316, 58.593]
ALL DOGE DATA
current_price = 0.200365, current_ema20 = 0.2, current_macd = 0.0, current_rsi (7 period) = 48.356
In addition, here is the latest DOGE open interest and funding rate for perps:
Open Interest: Latest: 577191282.0 Average: 577138663.6
Funding Rate: 1.19452e-05
Intraday series (3‑minute intervals, oldest → latest):
DOGE mid prices: [0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.201, 0.201, 0.2, 0.200365]
EMA indicators (20‑period): [0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2]
MACD indicators: [0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0]
RSI indicators (7‑Period): [43.273, 50.784, 43.164, 33.321, 46.92, 55.132, 61.992, 65.941, 48.356, 48.356]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [49.143, 52.37, 48.576, 42.925, 49.069, 53.24, 57.029, 59.336, 50.566, 50.566]
Longer‑term context (4‑hour timeframe):
20‑Period EMA: 0.194 vs. 50‑Period EMA: 0.199
3‑Period ATR: 0.002 vs. 14‑Period ATR: 0.004
Current Volume: 75658.0 vs. Average Volume: 86436575.858
MACD indicators: [-0.004, -0.003, -0.003, -0.002, -0.002, -0.001, -0.001, -0.0, 0.001, 0.001]
RSI indicators (14‑Period): [45.729, 47.476, 44.737, 52.051, 56.098, 56.701, 53.273, 59.278, 61.04, 59.522]
HERE IS YOUR ACCOUNT INFORMATION & PERFORMANCE
Current Total Return (percent): 32.62%
Available Cash: 3179.48
Current Account Value: 13262.44
Current live positions & performance: {'symbol': 'ETH', 'quantity': 5.06, 'entry_price': 3851.1, 'current_price': 4033.45, 'liquidation_price': 3670.09, 'unrealized_pnl': 922.69, 'leverage': 15, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 4171.75, 'stop_loss': 3722.49, 'invalidation_condition': 'If 4-hour MACD crosses below -80'}, 'confidence': 0.7, 'risk_usd': 650.916, 'sl_oid': 204621559787, 'tp_oid': 204621543867, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 204621535484, 'notional_usd': 20409.26} {'symbol': 'SOL', 'quantity': 60.44, 'entry_price': 184.9, 'current_price': 192.505, 'liquidation_price': 170.74, 'unrealized_pnl': 459.65, 'leverage': 10, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 200.237, 'stop_loss': 177.989, 'invalidation_condition': 'If 4-hour MACD crosses below -5'}, 'confidence': 0.6, 'risk_usd': 449.6, 'sl_oid': 204604011273, 'tp_oid': 204603997696, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 204603984402, 'notional_usd': 11635.0} {'symbol': 'XRP', 'quantity': 2303.0, 'entry_price': 2.43, 'current_price': 2.44935, 'liquidation_price': 2.25, 'unrealized_pnl': 33.74, 'leverage': 10, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 2.725, 'stop_loss': 2.336, 'invalidation_condition': 'If 4-hour MACD crosses below -0.05'}, 'confidence': 0.65, 'risk_usd': 224.41, 'sl_oid': -1, 'tp_oid': -1, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 206787882116, 'notional_usd': 5640.85} {'symbol': 'BTC', 'quantity': 0.28, 'entry_price': 107313.6, 'current_price': 110749.5, 'liquidation_price': 103341.98, 'unrealized_pnl': 962.05, 'leverage': 20, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 112218.5, 'stop_loss': 105774.5, 'invalidation_condition': 'If 4-hour MACD crosses below -2000'}, 'confidence': 0.65, 'risk_usd': 450, 'sl_oid': 204601782276, 'tp_oid': 204601767128, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 204601751388, 'notional_usd': 31009.86} {'symbol': 'DOGE', 'quantity': 68396.0, 'entry_price': 0.19, 'current_price': 0.200365, 'liquidation_price': 0.18, 'unrealized_pnl': 958.3, 'leverage': 10, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 0.214303, 'stop_loss': 0.177039, 'invalidation_condition': 'If price closes below 0.18 on 4-hour timeframe'}, 'confidence': 0.65, 'risk_usd': 637.876, 'sl_oid': -1, 'tp_oid': -1, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 204608277516, 'notional_usd': 13704.16} {'symbol': 'BNB', 'quantity': 7.07, 'entry_price': 1076.9, 'current_price': 1110.85, 'liquidation_price': 1019.6, 'unrealized_pnl': 240.03, 'leverage': 10, 'exit_plan': {'profit_target': 1142.958, 'stop_loss': 1045.896, 'invalidation_condition': 'If 4-hour MACD crosses below -40'}, 'confidence': 0.65, 'risk_usd': 229.5, 'sl_oid': 204618994700, 'tp_oid': 204618980456, 'wait_for_fill': False, 'entry_oid': 204618969527, 'notional_usd': 7853.71}
Sharpe Ratio: 0.019
#19 Re: deepseek炒股第一名
短线意义才大。
抄短线是AI优势最大的地方，短时间数据获取+分析+算力都是人力不可比拟的，可以算是看着你的牌出牌，长线AI优势就没了，整个世界政治经济体系的变化不是简单大数据模型能够分析出来的。长线人脑是优势，AI是劣势。
短线都赢不了，长线就更没戏了
x1
