哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

版主: kazaawangwh

wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#1 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2024 ... n-harvard/

HARVARD PRESIDENT CLAUDINE GAY RESIGNS, SHORTEST TENURE IN UNIVERSITY HISTORY
图片
Harvard President Claudine Gay will step down less than one month after her controversial testimony before Congress. By Miles J. Herszenhorn

By Emma H. Haidar and Cam E. Kettles, Crimson Staff Writers
36 minutes ago

Harvard President Claudine Gay will resign Tuesday afternoon, bringing an end to the shortest presidency in the University's history, according to a person with knowledge of the decision.

It is not clear who will be appointed to serve as interim president.

University spokesperson Jonathan L. Swain declined to comment on Gay's decision to step down.

Gay’s resignation — just six months and two days into the presidency — comes amid growing allegations of plagiarism and lasting doubts over her ability to respond to antisemitism on campus after her disastrous congressional testimony Dec. 5.

Gay weathered scandal after scandal over her brief tenure, facing national backlash for her administration’s response to Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack and allegations of plagiarism in her scholarly work.

The Corporation — the University’s highest governing body — is expected to announce the resignation to Harvard affiliates in an email later today. Gay is also expected to make a statement about the decision.

The announcement comes three weeks after the Corporation announced unanimous support for Gay after “extensive deliberations” following the congressional hearing.

This story will be updated.
kanting
著名点评
著名点评
帖子互动: 287
帖子: 5191
注册时间: 2022年 9月 15日 09:52

#2 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 kanting »

她想保住终身教授位子。把她弄出来的支持她的某些董事会重要成员或主席也得去职务并被追责吧。
wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#3 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

kanting 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 13:40 她想保住终身教授位子。
哦,弃卒保车啊。有用吗?她那个plagiarism有没有严重到学校调查的地步?没看新闻,不知道怎么plagiarize了。
kanting
著名点评
著名点评
帖子互动: 287
帖子: 5191
注册时间: 2022年 9月 15日 09:52

#4 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 kanting »

wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 13:44 哦,弃卒保车啊。有用吗?她那个plagiarism有没有严重到学校调查的地步?没看新闻,不知道怎么plagiarize了。
学校立案调查了,哈佛董事会的结论是有问题。问题不大。大约十天前的时候,严重抄袭(大段逐字抄袭抄袭)证据呈现在学术圈内,无可置疑。校长必须辞(实际是解职)。现在的情况是终身教授位能不能保住。按学术问题性质本身保不住。不过她是和肤色性别可能可以保护她。美国政治家不会吧事情做得那么难看。人家是个黑人又是个女人,这么弄大家脸上都很难看,下这手会很难看。她也是受害者,是你们有人要把她弄出来的做花瓶的。即使教授位保不住也不会马上开除或让她马上辞,过一段时间人让她自己以健康或家庭原因悄悄低调辞职。这个校长位的辞职看上去是解职,因为是董事会先发的电邮。解职的理由大概是学术抄袭不是国会听证的事。校长辞职电邮要在稍后发出。
RJZN(人间指南)
见习点评
见习点评
帖子互动: 282
帖子: 1936
注册时间: 2023年 3月 27日 10:13

#5 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 RJZN(人间指南) »

Dear Members of the Harvard Community,

It is with a heavy heart but a deep love for Harvard that I write to share that I will be stepping down as president. This is not a decision I came to easily. Indeed, it has been difficult beyond words because I have looked forward to working with so many of you to advance the commitment to academic excellence that has propelled this great university across centuries. But, after consultation with members of the Corporation, it has become clear that it is in the best interests of Harvard for me to resign so that our community can navigate this moment of extraordinary challenge with a focus on the institution rather than any individual.

It is a singular honor to be a member of this university, which has been my home and my inspiration for most of my professional career. My deep sense of connection to Harvard and its people has made it all the more painful to witness the tensions and divisions that have riven our community in recent months, weakening the bonds of trust and reciprocity that should be our sources of strength and support in times of crisis. Amidst all of this, it has been distressing to have doubt cast on my commitments to confronting hate and to upholding scholarly rigor — two bedrock values that are fundamental to who I am — and frightening to be subjected to personal attacks and threats fueled by racial animus.

I believe in the people of Harvard because I see in you the possibility and the promise of a better future. These last weeks have helped make clear the work we need to do to build that future — to combat bias and hate in all its forms, to create a learning environment in which we respect each other’s dignity and treat one another with compassion, and to affirm our enduring commitment to open inquiry and free expression in the pursuit of truth. I believe we have within us all that we need to heal from this period of tension and division and to emerge stronger. I had hoped with all my heart to lead us on that journey, in partnership with all of you. As I now return to the faculty, and to the scholarship and teaching that are the lifeblood of what we do, I pledge to continue working alongside you to build the community we all deserve.

When I became president, I considered myself particularly blessed by the opportunity to serve people from around the world who saw in my presidency a vision of Harvard that affirmed their sense of belonging — their sense that Harvard welcomes people of talent and promise, from every background imaginable, to learn from and grow with one another. To all of you, please know that those doors remain open, and Harvard will be stronger and better because they do.

As we welcome a new year and a new semester, I hope we can all look forward to brighter days. Sad as I am to be sending this message, my hopes for Harvard remain undimmed. When my brief presidency is remembered, I hope it will be seen as a moment of reawakening to the importance of striving to find our common humanity — and of not allowing rancor and vituperation to undermine the vital process of education. I trust we will all find ways, in this time of intense challenge and controversy, to recommit ourselves to the excellence, the openness, and the independence that are crucial to what our university stands for — and to our capacity to serve the world.

Sincerely,
Claudine Gay
wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#6 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

kanting 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:00 学校立案调查了,哈佛董事会的结论是有问题。问题不大。大约十天前的时候,严重抄袭(大段逐字抄袭抄袭)证据呈现在学术圈内,无可置疑。校长必须辞(实际是解职)。现在的情况是终身教授位能不能保住。按学术问题性质本身保不住。不过她是和肤色性别可能可以保护她。美国政治家不会吧事情做得那么难看。人家黑人有是女人这么弄,大家脸上都很难看,下不去手。她也是受害者,是你们有人要把她弄出来的做花瓶的。即使教授位保不住也不会马上开除或让她马上辞,过一段时间人让她自己以健康或家庭原因悄悄低调辞职。这个校长位的辞职看上去是解职,因为是董事会先发的电邮。解职的理由大概是学术抄袭不是国会听证的事。校长辞职电邮要在稍后发出。
找了一下新闻,她抄袭的不是思想创意,好像都是例行公事用语?她是英语不好吗?这太亏了。也有人说当时的学术规范不像现在那么严格。我以前大学也有个老师被调查,国内八十年代也确实学术不够规范。后来被人揭发的往往是风头比较劲、得罪了一大波人的学者。当时学校是保住了这位老师的,老师是很有才,学术成果卓越。当年论文没有严谨标出所有引用,有欠缺,但不影响学术成果。不过那次风波对他打击很大。不太清楚哈佛校长是不是也类似。不过照说美国90年代对学术引用已经要求得相当严格了。她可能做事比较粗,觉得致谢语什么的随便搬用无妨……

还没看到学校董事会发的公告,估计会说校长提出辞职,董事会接受吧?解职好像会影响pension,一般老师都选择辞职。希望不会太影响她的学术生涯;为了几句公事用语而断送学术太可惜了。

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/02/us/h ... arism.html
Harvard’s President Faces New Plagiarism Accusations
...
Some academics have said that Dr. Gay’s alleged offenses may reflect practices that were widespread in academia at the time of publication but have been tightened up since the advent of online plagiarism-detecting software.

She has not been accused of stealing big ideas, but rather of copying language in the papers of other scholars, with small changes to substitute words or phrases or to arrange them differently. Often the language in question is technical boilerplate.

In a typical example, the new complaint accurately quotes Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, “Taking Charge: Black Electoral Success and the Redefinition of American Politics”: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters for precinct i is derived by the slice it’s tomography line cuts out of this bivariate distribution.”

The complaint quotes a similar line from Gary King, a Harvard political scientist, who was her thesis adviser and whom she credits in her acknowledgments: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters within the bounds indicated by its tomography line is derived by the slice it cuts out of the bivariate distribution of all lines.”

...

The accuser goes on to wonder why Harvard was so intent on exposing him or her: “Did Gay wish to personally thank me for helping her to improve her work even if I drove her harder than she wanted to be driven?”

The sentence is an allusion to a phrase in the acknowledgments of Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, where she says that her family “drove me harder than I sometimes wanted to be driven.”

It is one of the phrases she is accused of copying, from the acknowledgments of a 1996 book, “Facing Up to the American Dream: Race, Class, and the Soul of the Nation,” by the Harvard political scientist Jennifer L. Hochschild, who was thanking another academic.
kanting
著名点评
著名点评
帖子互动: 287
帖子: 5191
注册时间: 2022年 9月 15日 09:52

#7 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 kanting »

wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:28 找了一下新闻,她抄袭的不是思想创意,好像都是例行公事用语?她是英语不好吗?这太亏了。也有人说当时的学术规范不像现在那么严格。我以前大学也有个老师被调查,国内八十年代也确实学术不够规范。后来被人揭发的往往是风头比较劲、得罪了一大波人的学者。当时学校是保住了这位老师的,老师是很有才,学术成果卓越。当年论文没有严谨标出所有引用,有欠缺,但不影响学术成果。不过那次风波对他打击很大。不太清楚哈佛校长是不是也类似。不过照说美国90年代对学术引用已经要求得相当严格了。她可能做事比较粗,觉得致谢语什么的随便搬用无妨……

还没看到学校董事会发的公告,估计会说校长提出辞职,董事会接受吧?解职好像会影响pension,一般老师都选择辞职。希望不会太影响她的学术生涯;为了几句公事用语而断送学术太可惜了。

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/02/us/h ... arism.html
Harvard’s President Faces New Plagiarism Accusations
...
Some academics have said that Dr. Gay’s alleged offenses may reflect practices that were widespread in academia at the time of publication but have been tightened up since the advent of online plagiarism-detecting software.

She has not been accused of stealing big ideas, but rather of copying language in the papers of other scholars, with small changes to substitute words or phrases or to arrange them differently. Often the language in question is technical boilerplate.

In a typical example, the new complaint accurately quotes Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, “Taking Charge: Black Electoral Success and the Redefinition of American Politics”: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters for precinct i is derived by the slice it’s tomography line cuts out of this bivariate distribution.”

The complaint quotes a similar line from Gary King, a Harvard political scientist, who was her thesis adviser and whom she credits in her acknowledgments: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters within the bounds indicated by its tomography line is derived by the slice it cuts out of the bivariate distribution of all lines.”

...

The accuser goes on to wonder why Harvard was so intent on exposing him or her: “Did Gay wish to personally thank me for helping her to improve her work even if I drove her harder than she wanted to be driven?”

The sentence is an allusion to a phrase in the acknowledgments of Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, where she says that her family “drove me harder than I sometimes wanted to be driven.”

It is one of the phrases she is accused of copying, from the acknowledgments of a 1996 book, “Facing Up to the American Dream: Race, Class, and the Soul of the Nation,” by the Harvard political scientist Jennifer L. Hochschild, who was thanking another academic.
我没查。大约年底12月20日左右以为普林斯顿的哈佛校长同行当面告诉我说有了哈佛校长大段逐句抄袭的证据,从学术角度讲是铁证,她肯定不行了,保不住。这位朋友原先还是为哈佛校长辩护说情的。
上次由 kanting 在 2024年 1月 2日 14:47 修改。
wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#8 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

RJZN 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:24 Dear Members of the Harvard Community,

It is with a heavy heart but a deep love for Harvard that I write to share that I will be stepping down as president. This is not a decision I came to easily. Indeed, it has been difficult beyond words because I have looked forward to working with so many of you to advance the commitment to academic excellence that has propelled this great university across centuries. But, after consultation with members of the Corporation, it has become clear that it is in the best interests of Harvard for me to resign so that our community can navigate this moment of extraordinary challenge with a focus on the institution rather than any individual.

It is a singular honor to be a member of this university, which has been my home and my inspiration for most of my professional career. My deep sense of connection to Harvard and its people has made it all the more painful to witness the tensions and divisions that have riven our community in recent months, weakening the bonds of trust and reciprocity that should be our sources of strength and support in times of crisis. Amidst all of this, it has been distressing to have doubt cast on my commitments to confronting hate and to upholding scholarly rigor — two bedrock values that are fundamental to who I am — and frightening to be subjected to personal attacks and threats fueled by racial animus.

I believe in the people of Harvard because I see in you the possibility and the promise of a better future. These last weeks have helped make clear the work we need to do to build that future — to combat bias and hate in all its forms, to create a learning environment in which we respect each other’s dignity and treat one another with compassion, and to affirm our enduring commitment to open inquiry and free expression in the pursuit of truth. I believe we have within us all that we need to heal from this period of tension and division and to emerge stronger. I had hoped with all my heart to lead us on that journey, in partnership with all of you. As I now return to the faculty, and to the scholarship and teaching that are the lifeblood of what we do, I pledge to continue working alongside you to build the community we all deserve.

When I became president, I considered myself particularly blessed by the opportunity to serve people from around the world who saw in my presidency a vision of Harvard that affirmed their sense of belonging — their sense that Harvard welcomes people of talent and promise, from every background imaginable, to learn from and grow with one another. To all of you, please know that those doors remain open, and Harvard will be stronger and better because they do.

As we welcome a new year and a new semester, I hope we can all look forward to brighter days. Sad as I am to be sending this message, my hopes for Harvard remain undimmed. When my brief presidency is remembered, I hope it will be seen as a moment of reawakening to the importance of striving to find our common humanity — and of not allowing rancor and vituperation to undermine the vital process of education. I trust we will all find ways, in this time of intense challenge and controversy, to recommit ourselves to the excellence, the openness, and the independence that are crucial to what our university stands for — and to our capacity to serve the world.

Sincerely,
Claudine Gay
她有没有为那些论文里大致照抄的词句道过歉?这个是硬伤啊,即使她再怎么自辩有scholarly rigor,还是得为这些虽然不伤筋骨、但明显是抄袭的词句道歉啊,否则会更让人攻击。
哈佛董事会的公告也出来了吗?这新年过得太不安生了 :(
kanting
著名点评
著名点评
帖子互动: 287
帖子: 5191
注册时间: 2022年 9月 15日 09:52

#9 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 kanting »

wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:28 找了一下新闻,她抄袭的不是思想创意,好像都是例行公事用语?她是英语不好吗?这太亏了。也有人说当时的学术规范不像现在那么严格。我以前大学也有个老师被调查,国内八十年代也确实学术不够规范。后来被人揭发的往往是风头比较劲、得罪了一大波人的学者。当时学校是保住了这位老师的,老师是很有才,学术成果卓越。当年论文没有严谨标出所有引用,有欠缺,但不影响学术成果。不过那次风波对他打击很大。不太清楚哈佛校长是不是也类似。不过照说美国90年代对学术引用已经要求得相当严格了。她可能做事比较粗,觉得致谢语什么的随便搬用无妨……

还没看到学校董事会发的公告,估计会说校长提出辞职,董事会接受吧?解职好像会影响pension,一般老师都选择辞职。希望不会太影响她的学术生涯;为了几句公事用语而断送学术太可惜了。

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/02/us/h ... arism.html
Harvard’s President Faces New Plagiarism Accusations
...
Some academics have said that Dr. Gay’s alleged offenses may reflect practices that were widespread in academia at the time of publication but have been tightened up since the advent of online plagiarism-detecting software.

She has not been accused of stealing big ideas, but rather of copying language in the papers of other scholars, with small changes to substitute words or phrases or to arrange them differently. Often the language in question is technical boilerplate.

In a typical example, the new complaint accurately quotes Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, “Taking Charge: Black Electoral Success and the Redefinition of American Politics”: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters for precinct i is derived by the slice it’s tomography line cuts out of this bivariate distribution.”

The complaint quotes a similar line from Gary King, a Harvard political scientist, who was her thesis adviser and whom she credits in her acknowledgments: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters within the bounds indicated by its tomography line is derived by the slice it cuts out of the bivariate distribution of all lines.”

...

The accuser goes on to wonder why Harvard was so intent on exposing him or her: “Did Gay wish to personally thank me for helping her to improve her work even if I drove her harder than she wanted to be driven?”

The sentence is an allusion to a phrase in the acknowledgments of Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, where she says that her family “drove me harder than I sometimes wanted to be driven.”

It is one of the phrases she is accused of copying, from the acknowledgments of a 1996 book, “Facing Up to the American Dream: Race, Class, and the Soul of the Nation,” by the Harvard political scientist Jennifer L. Hochschild, who was thanking another academic.
我没查。她的英文肯定没问题,土生的美国人,美国留学生第二代。大约年底12月20日左右以为普林斯顿的哈佛校长同行当面告诉我说有了哈佛校长大段逐句抄袭的证据,从学术角度讲是铁证,她肯定不行了,保不住。这位朋友原先还是为哈佛校长辩护说情的。普林斯顿没有法学院但有这位校长的专业政治学习,而且普林斯顿的政治学系是仅次于数学系、哲学系等的普林斯顿的最好的系之一。我猜这位朋友拿到抄袭材料这么早,可能是哈佛校方在请资深同行专家对抄袭举报材料做鉴定写下他的专家意见。
lonelyarcher
见习点评
见习点评
帖子互动: 145
帖子: 2027
注册时间: 2022年 7月 23日 21:41

#11 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 lonelyarcher »

这里人真这么蠢吗
还有人真的以为她因为抄袭辞职的
不要自欺欺人,只是一个冠冕堂皇的借口而已
wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#12 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

kanting 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:47 我没查。她的英文肯定没问题,土生的美国人,美国留学生第二代。大约年底12月20日左右以为普林斯顿的哈佛校长同行当面告诉我说有了哈佛校长大段逐句抄袭的证据,从学术角度讲是铁证,她肯定不行了,保不住。这位朋友原先还是为哈佛校长辩护说情的。普林斯顿没有法学院但有这位校长的专业政治学习,而且普林斯顿的政治学系还是仅次于数学系、哲学系等最好的系之一。我猜这位朋友拿到抄袭材料这么早,可能是哈佛校方在请资深同行专家做鉴定写下对这些抄袭的判断意见。
嗯,看她的辞职信措辞很漂亮。美国校长的语言功夫应该都很过硬。那她当时就是偷懒了。性格可能也不很严谨。你那位同行朋友多半是调查委员会的了。校长也应该不会有更严重的抄袭,否则爆料的早爆了,新闻也早发了。上面那篇新闻里引用的那两句实在无足轻重,不过搞事的不嫌事小。她的身份又那么敏感。再加上哈马斯雪上加霜。辞了就辞了吧,也轰轰烈烈了一把……学校太受各种政治风波影响了,真是放不下一张平静的书桌了。
aragorn(读万卷书,投万里毒)
见习作家
见习作家
帖子互动: 45
帖子: 410
注册时间: 2022年 7月 26日 00:46

#17 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 aragorn(读万卷书,投万里毒) »

本来就是个向忠发,运气好点浑浑噩噩混到退休就行了。结果运气不好撞上枪口被抓倒霉了。

混学术界的被揪出来抄袭,和闹革命的叛变投敌,做医生的被发现庸医害人,带兵打仗的临阵脱逃,码农写的低级bug搞垮整个公司系统一样,都是本行业最丢脸的事。没人会想要这个"借口"来体面下台的。不信去问问方励之,是愿意当年那样因为政治立场下台出国,还是更愿意被土共找出来实锤本科论文抄袭。换我要是有一天去当administrator,我宁愿因为跟研究生关系暧昧被人抓把柄,也绝对不想因为学术不端丢人现眼。
我喝了碗开水。
-水这种既没营养又没味道的东西真有XX喝? -喝的都是矿物质溶液,得多XX才相信喝到的真的是水?
-在美国喝不惯凉水还非得喝开水的,不是53就是刚下船的吧?-喝水还用碗的,肯定是小镇做题家。
-说“喝了碗开水”就够了。还画蛇添足加个“我”。中学语文是体育老师教的吧?
-眼看他起高楼,眼看他喝开水,眼看他楼塌了。
RJZN(人间指南)
见习点评
见习点评
帖子互动: 282
帖子: 1936
注册时间: 2023年 3月 27日 10:13

#19 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 RJZN(人间指南) »

wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:42 她有没有为那些论文里大致照抄的词句道过歉?这个是硬伤啊,即使她再怎么自辩有scholarly rigor,还是得为这些虽然不伤筋骨、但明显是抄袭的词句道歉啊,否则会更让人攻击。
哈佛董事会的公告也出来了吗?这新年过得太不安生了 :(
这事情背后确实很复杂,我说一些相关信息,有的是verfied,有的是传闻,大家姑妄听之。

首先是CG确实抄袭了,说不上严重,但是不止一次出现这类问题,情节有些恶劣,没有狡辩余地。

这事儿闹大的时间很耐人寻味。关于CG抄袭的讨论最初在网上出现,据说可以推到四年之前。我没看到四年前的讨论,但大概半年之前有所耳闻。三个校长听证会之后这事儿才被捅到媒体,这背后没有学术之外的动机,我不相信。

大概两周之前网上传言说有人拿了CG博士论文的数据把分析重做了一遍,不能复制她的结果,说一月份会把相关材料提交给哈佛。哈佛刚刚处理了商学院的作假大神Francesca Gino,CG如果做了同样的事情,那丢脸可真的要丢到家了。

+3.00 积分 [版主 wh. 发放的奖励]
wh(问号)楼主
论坛元老
论坛元老
wh 的博客
帖子互动: 3502
帖子: 76113
注册时间: 2022年 7月 28日 00:07

#20 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 wh(问号)楼主 »

Saysay1 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 15:05 就事论事,抄袭 难道不应该辞职吗?

如果她不是黑女,早就滚蛋了。
当然如果她不是黑女,也当不了校长。

恶心的是美国搞肤色正确,性别正确这一套。

从中国过来的很多学生,的确不把抄袭太当回事。我刚到美国时有一次做作业抄了书上一句话来答题,被教授严厉指出这是抄袭,应该给出引用出处,下次再犯就记0分,当时觉得无地自容,印象深刻啊。
是,我读研时我们一个外教也说我们的引用都不严格,谆谆教导我们要是在美国会被告剽窃的,即使一两个词也不要怕麻烦,一定要用引号,要写source。还说这和中文的典故不同,古诗文引用典故讲究不着一字,尽得风流;但学术论文切忌风流 ;) 我也印象很深,很汗颜。

不过抄袭还是有程度和质量区别的。你看她被爆的抄袭的字句,基本是我写一句叩谢saysay1,她抄一句拜谢vladputin。或者我写切一片蛋糕,她抄切一块蛋糕。不影响主题,但确实是抄了。哈佛第一次调查报告说是“...found multiple instances of improper citation, though the review concluded the errors did not amount to research misconduct."(https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023 ... extension/)

Crimson校报上还有个更详细地对比抄袭文字的新闻,拉到当中看红蓝highlight的对比:
https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023 ... sertation/
被抄的人和哈佛调查委员会口径一致,要么觉得不算剽窃:
“Bobo, King, and Gilliam all said they did not feel Gay plagiarized their work.”
要么觉得技术上是剽窃,但无足轻重:
”Voss ... said the work was “technically plagiarism,” but described it as “minor-to-inconsequential.”

而主控她的人说话真是难听,也毫不讳言挑事的动机:
"In a post on X Sunday night, right-wing activist Christopher F. Rufo said he and journalist Christopher Brunet intentionally released the story amid calls for Gay’s ouster as Harvard’s governing boards met to discuss the controversy surrounding her testimony.

“@RealChrisBrunet and I sat on the Claudine Gay plagiarism materials for the past week, waiting for the precise moment of maximum impact,” Rufo wrote. “The Harvard board is meeting tonight and there are rumors that the plagiarism scandal could be the final nail in Gay's coffin.”"

他们也确实有犹太大财主支持:
"The claim was amplified by Bill A. Ackman ’88, a hedge fund CEO who has been a vocal critic of Gay and has called for her resignation."

Bill Ackman是Ashkenazi Jewish descent (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ackman),给哈佛捐款数千万:
https://newrepublic.com/article/177598/ ... ond-market
"Ackman, age 57, is worth a reported $3.9 billion, and he's given Harvard tens of millions over the years, including $25 million in 2014. He has nearly one million followers on X."

校长确有把柄,再加上政治因素火上浇油,就把事情搞大了。她捍卫自己的scholarly rigor,大概因为如果道歉,就没法在学术圈里混了?
x1 图片
头像
sugarbabylove(维吾尔族餐厅厨师)
论坛支柱
论坛支柱
帖子互动: 1055
帖子: 11782
注册时间: 2023年 1月 18日 11:45

#23 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 sugarbabylove(维吾尔族餐厅厨师) »

Saysay1 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 16:53 左派认为:
1.学术抄袭不算啥(因为他们自己也抄?)
2. 盖伊当校长不是因为肤色
3. 盖伊被迫辞职是种族主义偏见
第一点没法评论,因为太建了。 :D


后两点其实你换个说法

盖伊当校长不是因为肤色
盖伊被迫辞职是因为肤色


反正怎么对它们有利它们就怎么说呗。

呵呵后。
x1 图片
鱼找鱼,虾找虾,剩下哒,我忘啦 :lol:
黑色的好吃,我每天都要吃。🤤🤤🤤
第一印象差的某些男id,现在看来印象依然很差。 :lol:
RJZN(人间指南)
见习点评
见习点评
帖子互动: 282
帖子: 1936
注册时间: 2023年 3月 27日 10:13

#25 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 RJZN(人间指南) »

你说的国内这位是北大王mm吧?王一直还在学术圈,还写东西,不过这么大个污点,真正搞学术的人顶多会表示几分谅解,尊敬就再也谈不上了。
wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 14:28 找了一下新闻,她抄袭的不是思想创意,好像都是例行公事用语?她是英语不好吗?这太亏了。也有人说当时的学术规范不像现在那么严格。我以前大学也有个老师被调查,国内八十年代也确实学术不够规范。后来被人揭发的往往是风头比较劲、得罪了一大波人的学者。当时学校是保住了这位老师的,老师是很有才,学术成果卓越。当年论文没有严谨标出所有引用,有欠缺,但不影响学术成果。不过那次风波对他打击很大。不太清楚哈佛校长是不是也类似。不过照说美国90年代对学术引用已经要求得相当严格了。她可能做事比较粗,觉得致谢语什么的随便搬用无妨……

还没看到学校董事会发的公告,估计会说校长提出辞职,董事会接受吧?解职好像会影响pension,一般老师都选择辞职。希望不会太影响她的学术生涯;为了几句公事用语而断送学术太可惜了。

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/02/us/h ... arism.html
Harvard’s President Faces New Plagiarism Accusations
...
Some academics have said that Dr. Gay’s alleged offenses may reflect practices that were widespread in academia at the time of publication but have been tightened up since the advent of online plagiarism-detecting software.

She has not been accused of stealing big ideas, but rather of copying language in the papers of other scholars, with small changes to substitute words or phrases or to arrange them differently. Often the language in question is technical boilerplate.

In a typical example, the new complaint accurately quotes Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, “Taking Charge: Black Electoral Success and the Redefinition of American Politics”: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters for precinct i is derived by the slice it’s tomography line cuts out of this bivariate distribution.”

The complaint quotes a similar line from Gary King, a Harvard political scientist, who was her thesis adviser and whom she credits in her acknowledgments: “The posterior distribution of each of the precinct parameters within the bounds indicated by its tomography line is derived by the slice it cuts out of the bivariate distribution of all lines.”

...

The accuser goes on to wonder why Harvard was so intent on exposing him or her: “Did Gay wish to personally thank me for helping her to improve her work even if I drove her harder than she wanted to be driven?”

The sentence is an allusion to a phrase in the acknowledgments of Dr. Gay’s 1997 dissertation, where she says that her family “drove me harder than I sometimes wanted to be driven.”

It is one of the phrases she is accused of copying, from the acknowledgments of a 1996 book, “Facing Up to the American Dream: Race, Class, and the Soul of the Nation,” by the Harvard political scientist Jennifer L. Hochschild, who was thanking another academic.
ferrygao
论坛元老
论坛元老
帖子互动: 774
帖子: 18455
注册时间: 2023年 8月 28日 11:36

#26 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 ferrygao »

还没办法治你了 滚粗
知道很多人的居住环境以后 我终于明白为啥会有这些想法了
Savage
论坛精英
论坛精英
帖子互动: 729
帖子: 7507
注册时间: 2022年 10月 4日 23:31

#28 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 Savage »

她的下台有偶然也有必然。

偶然:撞到政治枪口了。

必然:资历太浅。土共讲究履历完整,是有道理的。你没经历过风浪,开不了大船下海。
kanting
著名点评
著名点评
帖子互动: 287
帖子: 5191
注册时间: 2022年 9月 15日 09:52

#29 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 kanting »

wh. 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 16:14 是,我读研时我们一个外教也说我们的引用都不严格,谆谆教导我们要是在美国会被告剽窃的,即使一两个词也不要怕麻烦,一定要用引号,要写source。还说这和中文的典故不同,古诗文引用典故讲究不着一字,尽得风流;但学术论文切忌风流 ;) 我也印象很深,很汗颜。

不过抄袭还是有程度和质量区别的。你看她被爆的抄袭的字句,基本是我写一句叩谢saysay1,她抄一句拜谢vladputin。或者我写切一片蛋糕,她抄切一块蛋糕。不影响主题,但确实是抄了。哈佛第一次调查报告说是“...found multiple instances of improper citation, though the review concluded the errors did not amount to research misconduct."(https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023 ... extension/)

Crimson校报上还有个更详细地对比抄袭文字的新闻,拉到当中看红蓝highlight的对比:
https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2023 ... sertation/
被抄的人和哈佛调查委员会口径一致,要么觉得不算剽窃:
“Bobo, King, and Gilliam all said they did not feel Gay plagiarized their work.”
要么觉得技术上是剽窃,但无足轻重:
”Voss ... said the work was “technically plagiarism,” but described it as “minor-to-inconsequential.”

而主控她的人说话真是难听,也毫不讳言挑事的动机:
"In a post on X Sunday night, right-wing activist Christopher F. Rufo said he and journalist Christopher Brunet intentionally released the story amid calls for Gay’s ouster as Harvard’s governing boards met to discuss the controversy surrounding her testimony.

“@RealChrisBrunet and I sat on the Claudine Gay plagiarism materials for the past week, waiting for the precise moment of maximum impact,” Rufo wrote. “The Harvard board is meeting tonight and there are rumors that the plagiarism scandal could be the final nail in Gay's coffin.”"

他们也确实有犹太大财主支持:
"The claim was amplified by Bill A. Ackman ’88, a hedge fund CEO who has been a vocal critic of Gay and has called for her resignation."

Bill Ackman是Ashkenazi Jewish descent (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Ackman),给哈佛捐款数千万:
https://newrepublic.com/article/177598/ ... ond-market
"Ackman, age 57, is worth a reported $3.9 billion, and he's given Harvard tens of millions over the years, including $25 million in 2014. He has nearly one million followers on X."

校长确有把柄,再加上政治因素火上浇油,就把事情搞大了。她捍卫自己的scholarly rigor,大概因为如果道歉,就没法在学术圈里混了?
多谢。wh 仔细讨论的上文似乎不包括这篇哈佛董事会故意遗漏不讨论的哈佛董事会当时已经收到的新报告中的指控内容。我把RJZN转的文章的这部分以醒目字体突现。

RJZN楼主 » 2 分钟前

https://freebeacon.com/campus/harvard-p ... lagiarism/

Though Harvard's governing board, the Harvard Corporation, said in mid-December that it had reviewed Gay’s published oeuvre and found several cases of "inadequate citation," it did not identify any of the examples described in the new complaint, which was submitted to the school’s research integrity officer, Stacey Springs, and obtained by the Free Beacon.

The discrepancy raises troubling questions not just about the scope of Gay’s plagiarism, which appears to afflict half of her published works, but also the thoroughness and seriousness of the Corporation’s probe, which the board described as "an independent review by distinguished political scientists."

The review was completed in just a few weeks—far less time than the 6 to 12 months typical of other plagiarism investigations—and the Corporation has refused to disclose the names of the academics who conducted it. A Harvard spokesman, Jonathan Swain, did not respond to a request for comment about whether the school has reviewed all of Gay’s work, and, if so, how it missed the examples unearthed on Monday.

"The board’s review of Gay’s work was too brief to inspire confidence," the complaint reads. "So we now know for certain that the board’s investigation was a sham."
RJZN 写了: 2024年 1月 2日 20:47 https://freebeacon.com/campus/harvard-p ... lagiarism/

Though Harvard's governing board, the Harvard Corporation, said in mid-December that it had reviewed Gay’s published oeuvre and found several cases of "inadequate citation," it did not identify any of the examples described in the new complaint, which was submitted to the school’s research integrity officer, Stacey Springs, and obtained by the Free Beacon.

The discrepancy raises troubling questions not just about the scope of Gay’s plagiarism, which appears to afflict half of her published works, but also the thoroughness and seriousness of the Corporation’s probe, which the board described as "an independent review by distinguished political scientists."

The review was completed in just a few weeks—far less time than the 6 to 12 months typical of other plagiarism investigations—and the Corporation has refused to disclose the names of the academics who conducted it. A Harvard spokesman, Jonathan Swain, did not respond to a request for comment about whether the school has reviewed all of Gay’s work, and, if so, how it missed the examples unearthed on Monday.

"The board’s review of Gay’s work was too brief to inspire confidence," the complaint reads. "So we now know for certain that the board’s investigation was a sham."
x1 图片
cng(papabear)
论坛元老
论坛元老
帖子互动: 973
帖子: 15093
注册时间: 2022年 9月 11日 03:58

#30 Re: 哈佛校长下午辞职,创哈佛历史最短校长任期

帖子 cng(papabear) »

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semitic_people: "Semites is an obsolete term for an ethnic, cultural or racial group[2][3][4][5] associated with people of the Middle East, including Arabs, Jews, Akkadians, and Phoenicians."
Why antisemitism is defined as hostility to or prejudice against Jewish people?
raebapap
回复

回到 “书歌影视美食游 - 精华区”