去complain吧，就说它店里误导
买错酒不能退，我被Costco坑惨了
版主： kazaawang， wh
-
Zephyrca
- 论坛支柱
2024年度优秀版主
Zephyrca 的博客 - 帖子互动： 1257
- 帖子： 11375
- 注册时间： 2022年 8月 12日 22:10
保守派们欢迎来美国时政版：
#104 Re: 买错酒不能退，我被Costco坑惨了
我不是说价钱。而是说数量，你一边说这一箱要喝到猴年马月，一边又拿了一箱。你拿一箱的时候，难道是以为这箱子里只装了一瓶？如果这一箱就只卖70块，你就能短期内喝完了，就不说要喝到猴年马月了？
#106 Re: 买错酒不能退，我被Costco坑惨了
Gemini回答：
* A. Contrasting Return Paradigms: Alcohol vs. Ammunition vs. Tobacco
* Alcohol: Return policies for alcohol are characterized by stringent federal rules governing business-to-business transactions (TTB's consignment sales prohibitions ) and state laws that typically limit consumer returns to defective or spoiled products, or errors in sale. The core drivers are tax integrity, preventing illicit markets, ensuring product safety, and upholding the historical principles of the three-tier system and tied-house laws.
* Ammunition: Ammunition is almost universally non-returnable at the consumer level, a policy established by retailers. While often attributed broadly to "ATF regulations" , this is more accurately a consequence of overriding safety concerns (unknown storage, potential tampering), significant liability risks for retailers, difficulties in verifying the chain of custody, and the hazardous material classification of ammunition which complicates shipping. The ATF's role is one of general oversight of FFLs , rather than issuing specific mandates on consumer ammunition returns.
* Tobacco: Tobacco products are also generally non-returnable. This is due to a powerful combination of manufacturer agreements that contractually prohibit returns , FDA public health regulations aimed at ensuring product integrity and preventing youth access , and TTB considerations regarding excise tax collection. State laws typically permit retailers to enforce these restrictive policies as long as they are clearly posted.
* B. The Interplay of Federal Agencies (ATF, TTB, FDA)
The regulatory landscape for these products involves a division of labor among federal agencies:
* The ATF is the primary regulator for firearms and ammunition, focusing on licensing, preventing sales to prohibited persons, and ensuring FFL compliance. Its influence on ammunition returns is indirect, stemming from the overall strict compliance environment it fosters for FFLs.
* The TTB manages the tax and trade aspects of alcohol and tobacco. For alcohol, it sets the rules for returns between industry tiers (e.g., wholesaler to retailer). For tobacco, its main role is tax collection and permitting.
* The FDA holds comprehensive authority over tobacco products, prioritizing public health. This includes setting product standards, restricting marketing, and preventing youth access, all of which create strong disincentives for retailers to accept returned tobacco.
A shared theme is that the actions and mandates of these agencies, each operating within its specific sphere of authority, collectively contribute to a regulatory climate where returns are disfavored for these product categories. The primary reasons differ—security and control for ATF; tax and trade integrity for TTB; and public health for FDA—but the outcome is often similar: restricted returns.
* A. Contrasting Return Paradigms: Alcohol vs. Ammunition vs. Tobacco
* Alcohol: Return policies for alcohol are characterized by stringent federal rules governing business-to-business transactions (TTB's consignment sales prohibitions ) and state laws that typically limit consumer returns to defective or spoiled products, or errors in sale. The core drivers are tax integrity, preventing illicit markets, ensuring product safety, and upholding the historical principles of the three-tier system and tied-house laws.
* Ammunition: Ammunition is almost universally non-returnable at the consumer level, a policy established by retailers. While often attributed broadly to "ATF regulations" , this is more accurately a consequence of overriding safety concerns (unknown storage, potential tampering), significant liability risks for retailers, difficulties in verifying the chain of custody, and the hazardous material classification of ammunition which complicates shipping. The ATF's role is one of general oversight of FFLs , rather than issuing specific mandates on consumer ammunition returns.
* Tobacco: Tobacco products are also generally non-returnable. This is due to a powerful combination of manufacturer agreements that contractually prohibit returns , FDA public health regulations aimed at ensuring product integrity and preventing youth access , and TTB considerations regarding excise tax collection. State laws typically permit retailers to enforce these restrictive policies as long as they are clearly posted.
* B. The Interplay of Federal Agencies (ATF, TTB, FDA)
The regulatory landscape for these products involves a division of labor among federal agencies:
* The ATF is the primary regulator for firearms and ammunition, focusing on licensing, preventing sales to prohibited persons, and ensuring FFL compliance. Its influence on ammunition returns is indirect, stemming from the overall strict compliance environment it fosters for FFLs.
* The TTB manages the tax and trade aspects of alcohol and tobacco. For alcohol, it sets the rules for returns between industry tiers (e.g., wholesaler to retailer). For tobacco, its main role is tax collection and permitting.
* The FDA holds comprehensive authority over tobacco products, prioritizing public health. This includes setting product standards, restricting marketing, and preventing youth access, all of which create strong disincentives for retailers to accept returned tobacco.
A shared theme is that the actions and mandates of these agencies, each operating within its specific sphere of authority, collectively contribute to a regulatory climate where returns are disfavored for these product categories. The primary reasons differ—security and control for ATF; tax and trade integrity for TTB; and public health for FDA—but the outcome is often similar: restricted returns.
上次由 magagop 在 2025年 5月 14日 00:08 修改。
#107 Re: 买错酒不能退，我被Costco坑惨了
我靠，重口味。朗姆酒跟藿香正气水一样，竟然觉得香trskr 写了： 2025年 5月 14日 00:00 試試這一瓶，Glenfiddich 12 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky，很不錯也不貴，$40-50 。
x2
