这个医生收入的列表靠谱吗？🤔

[midlander]

这是income ranking $43万就进top 1%... 这样的话医生职业 大部份进入top 1%...
不晓得...

https://dqydj.com/income-percentile-calculator/

美国医生就是这样

[Dashabi01]

我听说麻醉科不错，平时又闲又干净。
眼科也不错，干净，不行的话就去开眼镜店，暴利行业。
皮肤科最恶心，需要很强的心里承受能力。

胡扯 皮肤科才是最干净

[Xiaofish]

感觉这个说法违反常识，我听到的是鸟不拉屎地方的医生收入比鸟粪堆积的地方要低。

你不懂。医生因为收入都可以，然后又苦了半辈子，都喜欢鸟拉屎的地方，能有点生活。不然，有钱了照样在鸟不拉屎地区苦逼，这辈子活了有啥意思？因此造成鸟不拉屎的地方没人去，所以只能给高工资。这才是常识，这才符合逻辑。

[gousheng]

这是Deep Seek给出的答案：

In the United States, doctors typically earn more money working in **developed regions** (urban or affluent areas) compared to **underdeveloped regions** (rural or underserved areas). However, there are some important nuances and exceptions to consider:

### **1. Higher Salaries in Developed Regions (Urban/Wealthy Areas)**
- **Higher patient volumes & more specialized care**: Urban areas have denser populations, allowing doctors to see more patients and perform more procedures.
- **Higher cost of living**: Cities like New York, Los Angeles, or Boston have higher salaries to offset living expenses.
- **More lucrative specialties & private practices**: Wealthier regions often have more demand for high-paying specialties (e.g., plastic surgery, cardiology) and private practice opportunities.

### **2. Financial Incentives in Underdeveloped Regions (Rural/Underserved Areas)**
- **Loan repayment programs**: The U.S. government (e.g., National Health Service Corps) and some states offer student loan forgiveness for doctors working in underserved areas.
- **Higher salaries in some rural areas**: Some rural hospitals pay **more** than urban counterparts due to difficulty attracting talent.
- **Tax incentives & bonuses**: Some states offer tax breaks or signing bonuses for rural physicians.
- **Lower competition & lower malpractice costs**: Rural doctors may have lower overhead costs.

### **3. Key Exceptions & Factors**
- **Specialty matters**: Primary care doctors in rural areas may earn **comparable or slightly more** than in cities due to demand, while specialists (e.g., neurosurgeons) earn far more in urban centers.
- **Public vs. private sector**: Doctors in urban academic hospitals may earn less than those in private practice, whereas rural doctors often have fewer high-paying alternatives.
- **State-specific policies**: Some states (e.g., Alaska, North Dakota) offer very high pay for rural doctors due to extreme shortages.

### **Conclusion**
- **On average, doctors earn more in developed regions** due to higher patient volumes, specialization, and cost-of-living adjustments.
- **However, some underdeveloped regions pay competitively (or even more) due to incentives**, especially for primary care and family medicine.

If maximizing income is the goal, doctors in **urban, high-demand specialties** usually earn the most. But those willing to work in **rural/underserved areas** can sometimes secure higher base salaries with added benefits like loan forgiveness.

你不懂。医生因为收入都可以，然后又苦了半辈子，都喜欢鸟拉屎的地方，能有点生活。不然，有钱了照样在鸟不拉屎地区苦逼，这辈子活了有啥意思？因此造成鸟不拉屎的地方没人去，所以只能给高工资。这才是常识，这才符合逻辑。

[swjtuer]

光坐诊，不做手术/procedure，不抢救，就挣不到钱。

家庭医生收入不高，不到二十万的样子

想多挣就得开诊所，或者能动刀

[alps5241]

美帝以后也没工厂了，都当医生律师

华人律师据说现在收入一般

[直接投降]

华人律师据说现在收入一般

律师早完了，洋人律师大多也不行

[皇军不抢粮]

扯。大米有一点奇葩，医生得鸟不拉屎地区才收入更高

熟食

[皇军不抢粮]

这是Deep Seek给出的答案：

In the United States, doctors typically earn more money working in **developed regions** (urban or affluent areas) compared to **underdeveloped regions** (rural or underserved areas). However, there are some important nuances and exceptions to consider:

### **1. Higher Salaries in Developed Regions (Urban/Wealthy Areas)**
- **Higher patient volumes & more specialized care**: Urban areas have denser populations, allowing doctors to see more patients and perform more procedures.
- **Higher cost of living**: Cities like New York, Los Angeles, or Boston have higher salaries to offset living expenses.
- **More lucrative specialties & private practices**: Wealthier regions often have more demand for high-paying specialties (e.g., plastic surgery, cardiology) and private practice opportunities.

### **2. Financial Incentives in Underdeveloped Regions (Rural/Underserved Areas)**
- **Loan repayment programs**: The U.S. government (e.g., National Health Service Corps) and some states offer student loan forgiveness for doctors working in underserved areas.
- **Higher salaries in some rural areas**: Some rural hospitals pay **more** than urban counterparts due to difficulty attracting talent.
- **Tax incentives & bonuses**: Some states offer tax breaks or signing bonuses for rural physicians.
- **Lower competition & lower malpractice costs**: Rural doctors may have lower overhead costs.

### **3. Key Exceptions & Factors**
- **Specialty matters**: Primary care doctors in rural areas may earn **comparable or slightly more** than in cities due to demand, while specialists (e.g., neurosurgeons) earn far more in urban centers.
- **Public vs. private sector**: Doctors in urban academic hospitals may earn less than those in private practice, whereas rural doctors often have fewer high-paying alternatives.
- **State-specific policies**: Some states (e.g., Alaska, North Dakota) offer very high pay for rural doctors due to extreme shortages.

### **Conclusion**
- **On average, doctors earn more in developed regions** due to higher patient volumes, specialization, and cost-of-living adjustments.
- **However, some underdeveloped regions pay competitively (or even more) due to incentives**, especially for primary care and family medicine.

If maximizing income is the goal, doctors in **urban, high-demand specialties** usually earn the most. But those willing to work in **rural/underserved areas** can sometimes secure higher base salaries with added benefits like loan forgiveness.

人工智能这种屁就算了吧……


我表姐大纽约的医科毕业。她们班的一个白皮志愿去乡下扶贫，年入近40万。留在纽约的20万都没有。这是近20年前的价码……