新未名空间

YouHi 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:01 只能surgeon，OBGYN，ER这种动手的才会有工作保障。

YouHi 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:03 原贴被删掉了？

VladPutin 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:05 显然收到了美国医学会之类的律师函，被吓到了。

VladPutin 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 09:57



医疗这个行业其实已经被AI取代了，只是这个利益集团还垂死挣扎。

Xiaofish 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:22 没有截图留底吗？想围观都不行？差评

Mountainlion 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:34 “ChatGPT solved a 10+ year problem no doctors could figure out,” the post read.

“For 10+ years I have had several unexplained symptoms. I had a spinal MRI, CT Scan, blood work (in depth), everything up to even checking for Lyme disease. I did function health (free plug I guess) and it turns out I have the homozygous A1298C MTHFR mutation which affects 7-12% of the population. I’m in the states and my doctor network is one of the top ranked in the nation. I even saw a neurologist at one point and checked for MS. ChatGPT took all my lab results and symptom history and concluded this was on par with the mutation,” the post further read.

Despite seemingly normal B12 levels, it turns out with the mutation it may not be utilizing them correctly so you need to boost it with supplementation. Ran these findings by my doctor and he was super shocked and said this all added up to him. Not sure how they didn’t think to test me for MTHFR mutation,” the post continued.

Anyways, here we are a few months later and my symptoms are largely resolved. Actually perplexed, and excited, at how this all went down up until now. EDIT: Didn’t expect this to get so much attention. Will reiterate and emphasize that I double checked the ai suggestion with my primary care provider before trying its suggestions. Please do not trust it all the time for medical advice,” the post concluded.

VladPutin 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:04 外科医生被器人取代也就是5-10年的事。事实上最精密的手术其实已经是机械手做了，加个人工智能代替医生齐活。

Mountainlion 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:34 “ChatGPT solved a 10+ year problem no doctors could figure out,” the post read.

“For 10+ years I have had several unexplained symptoms. I had a spinal MRI, CT Scan, blood work (in depth), everything up to even checking for Lyme disease. I did function health (free plug I guess) and it turns out I have the homozygous A1298C MTHFR mutation which affects 7-12% of the population. I’m in the states and my doctor network is one of the top ranked in the nation. I even saw a neurologist at one point and checked for MS. ChatGPT took all my lab results and symptom history and concluded this was on par with the mutation,” the post further read.

Despite seemingly normal B12 levels, it turns out with the mutation it may not be utilizing them correctly so you need to boost it with supplementation. Ran these findings by my doctor and he was super shocked and said this all added up to him. Not sure how they didn’t think to test me for MTHFR mutation,” the post continued.

Anyways, here we are a few months later and my symptoms are largely resolved. Actually perplexed, and excited, at how this all went down up until now. EDIT: Didn’t expect this to get so much attention. Will reiterate and emphasize that I double checked the ai suggestion with my primary care provider before trying its suggestions. Please do not trust it all the time for medical advice,” the post concluded.

Mountainlion 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:34 “ChatGPT solved a 10+ year problem no doctors could figure out,” the post read.

“For 10+ years I have had several unexplained symptoms. I had a spinal MRI, CT Scan, blood work (in depth), everything up to even checking for Lyme disease. I did function health (free plug I guess) and it turns out I have the homozygous A1298C MTHFR mutation which affects 7-12% of the population. I’m in the states and my doctor network is one of the top ranked in the nation. I even saw a neurologist at one point and checked for MS. ChatGPT took all my lab results and symptom history and concluded this was on par with the mutation,” the post further read.

Despite seemingly normal B12 levels, it turns out with the mutation it may not be utilizing them correctly so you need to boost it with supplementation. Ran these findings by my doctor and he was super shocked and said this all added up to him. Not sure how they didn’t think to test me for MTHFR mutation,” the post continued.

Anyways, here we are a few months later and my symptoms are largely resolved. Actually perplexed, and excited, at how this all went down up until now. EDIT: Didn’t expect this to get so much attention. Will reiterate and emphasize that I double checked the ai suggestion with my primary care provider before trying its suggestions. Please do not trust it all the time for medical advice,” the post concluded.

Xiaofish 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 10:43 这个其实挺常见的，这届医生不行

VladPutin 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 09:57



医疗这个行业其实已经被AI取代了，只是这个利益集团还垂死挣扎。

littlek 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 16:09 这个故事说明，学医也需要Phd, 光靠病人积累经验是不行的。这就是为啥top 5的residency program招人都要Md. Phd的原因。

MTHFR mutation这是个常见的话题，比如Harrison内科学第21版769页。我觉得很多board的MOC都会考这个topic.

littlek 写了： 2025年 7月 7日 16:13 是的，一般pathology report都做基因检测的，美国也跟中国一样，啥检验都走一边。