美国新闻版 祝贺 中华人民共和国国庆73周年！

[sweetsister]

你媳妇儿的钢琴弹得真好

赞一个

[Cellcycle2]

为啥是媳妇？？

[reknaz]

But how many people on this board are from Taiwan?

这很重要吗？台湾是中国的一部分，大陆也纪念辛亥革命。从某种程度来说，辛亥革命更能凝聚所有中国人。一边强调统一一边拿台湾人当敌人，幸亏共产党没有这么小气量。

[fortyNiner]

To me, Taiwan is jsut another province of China, just like Guangdong, Sichuan, or Yunnan. I normally don't praise or attack a particular province, so I don't care that much about a special day in Taiwan. If many people on this board are from Taiwan, I can see why they want to celebrate it. But if very few people on this board are from Taiwan, I don't see the point. For the same reason, we don't care much about or celebrate any holiday in Macau on this board.

这很重要吗？台湾是中国的一部分，大陆也纪念辛亥革命。从某种程度来说，辛亥革命更能凝聚所有中国人。一边强调统一一边拿台湾人当敌人，幸亏共产党没有这么小气量。

[reknaz]

To me, Taiwan is jsut another province of China, just like Guangdong, Sichuan, or Yunnan. I normally don't praise or attack a particular province, so I don't care that much about a special day in Taiwan. If many people on this board are from Taiwan, I can see why they want to celebrate it. But if very few people on this board are from Taiwan, I don't see the point. For the same reason, we don't care much about or celebrate any holiday in Macau on this board.

辛亥革命是中国历史上的革命运动，建立的中华民国也是全中国的中华民国，不论在大陆还是台湾都会纪念，形式不同而已。这是个属于所有中国人，不只是台湾省的重要日期。中国人不在乎辛亥革命，只能说心里没有中国历史，眼里的政府和军阀没有区别。

[fortyNiner]

Who says you have to celebrate 10/10 to 在乎辛亥革命? Who says 中国历史 is all about 辛亥革命? Do people in Taiwan still celebrate the day when China/Taiwan abolished the slavery system to 心里有中国历史?

辛亥革命是中国历史上的革命运动，建立的中华民国也是全中国的中华民国，不论在大陆还是台湾都会纪念，形式不同而已。这是个属于所有中国人，不只是台湾省的重要日期。中国人不在乎辛亥革命，只能说心里没有中国历史，眼里的政府和军阀没有区别。

[reknaz]

Who says you have to celebrate 10/10 to 在乎辛亥革命? Who says 中国历史 is all about 辛亥革命? Do people in Taiwan still celebrate the day when China/Taiwan abolished the slavery system to 心里有中国历史?

我说的是纪念，你不要转进成 celebrate，我明确说明纪念的形式不同，celebrate 只是一种形式。我没有说过中国历史全都是辛亥革命，劳驾不要无中生有，但 10/10 是整个中国的 special day，不是台湾的 special day。你这最后一个问题我完全看不懂，不知道你指的是什么。台湾人有一部分不认为自己是中国人，当然不会心里有中国历史。但 10/10 在历史上发生在大陆，历史意义属于全中国，在台湾另外一部分认为自己是中国人的心里当然是有分量的，台湾只要还 celebrate 10/10，就说明他们至少官方还是认同中国的名号。

[fortyNiner]

The title of this threat says "祝贺...", then some one said "希望10月10号的时候，美新版也能置顶中华民国双十国庆." Isn't that "celebrate"?
You said "中国人不在乎辛亥革命，只能说心里没有中国历史" . Some people care a lot about China's history, but not necessarily much about 辛亥革命. Do you still say "只能说 they 心里没有中国历史"?
Agree with you that 10/10 is China's special day, but not necessarily a special day to "celebrate". Most of us here, assuming very few here are from Taiwan, have never celebrated 10/10 before. So who will care to celebrate it now? Don't label us as "心里没有中国历史". We all have learned about it at grade schools, we appreciate its significance in China's history. We remember it, but we just don't "celebrate" it.
Maybe I am wrong. You can do a survey on this board to prove that I am wrong. You can ask how many people on this board will "celebrate" 10/10. Or we can just wait and see how many will come out "celebrate" it on that day.

我说的是纪念，你不要转进成 celebrate，我明确说明纪念的形式不同，celebrate 只是一种形式。我没有说过中国历史全都是辛亥革命，劳驾不要无中生有，但 10/10 是整个中国的 special day，不是台湾的 special day。你这最后一个问题我完全看不懂，不知道你指的是什么。台湾人有一部分不认为自己是中国人，当然不会心里有中国历史。但 10/10 在历史上发生在大陆，历史意义属于全中国，在台湾另外一部分认为自己是中国人的心里当然是有分量的，台湾只要还 celebrate 10/10，就说明他们至少官方还是认同中国的名号。

[reknaz]

我自始至终都没有提过 celebrate。我的观点很明确，台湾人也是中国人，10/10 的日期是属于所有中国而不是台湾。是你说 "I normally don't praise or attack a particular province, so I don't care that much about a special day in Taiwan." 把 10/10 首先解读成台湾的 special day，说明在你心里这个日期的含义首先是台湾的节日，代表台湾的政府。而辛亥革命这个名称才是10/10真正具有历史意义的名称。

The title of this threat says "祝贺...", then some one said "希望10月10号的时候，美新版也能置顶中华民国双十国庆." Isn't that "celebrate"?
You said "中国人不在乎辛亥革命，只能说心里没有中国历史" . Some people care a lot about China's history, but not necessarily much about 辛亥革命. Do you still say "只能说 they 心里没有中国历史"?
Agree with you that 10/10 is China's special day, but not necessarily a special day to "celebrate". Most of us here, assuming very few here are from Taiwan, have never celebrated 10/10 before. So who will care to celebrate it now? Don't label us as "心里没有中国历史". We all have learned about it at grade schools, we appreciate its significance in China's history. We remember it, but we just don't "celebrate" it.
Maybe I am wrong. You can do a survey on this board to prove that I am wrong. You can ask how many people on this board will "celebrate" 10/10. Or we can just wait and see how many will come out "celebrate" it on that day.

[fortyNiner]

It's a fact that 10/10 is a special day only in Taiwan. The rest of Chinese embrace but not celebrate it.
So seems there is nothing to argue here. Someone implied to 祝贺 10/10, I doubted if there were many people on this board to "celebrate" it, and then you asked if that was important.
My opinion on this topic is, since on this board there are not too many people from Taiwan, nobody cares to celebrate 10/10. By no means I implied 10/10 had no historical importance to China. But not celebrating 10/10 does not mean someone does not care about China's history. Anyway, almost none of China's 1.4 billion population does it.

我自始至终都没有提过 celebrate。我的观点很明确，台湾人也是中国人，10/10 的日期是属于所有中国而不是台湾。是你说 "I normally don't praise or attack a particular province, so I don't care that much about a special day in Taiwan." 把 10/10 首先解读成台湾的 special day，说明在你心里这个日期的含义首先是台湾的节日，代表台湾的政府。而辛亥革命这个名称才是10/10真正具有历史意义的名称。

[reknaz]

Special day 并不是只能 celebrate 的，五四，七七，九一八，一二九年年纪念，你都是 celebrate 的吗？还是你认为它们对中国来说不是 special days？

It's a fact that 10/10 is a special day only in Taiwan. The rest of Chinese embrace but not celebrate it.
So seems there is nothing to argue here. Someone implied to 祝贺 10/10, I doubted if there were many people on this board to "celebrate" it, and then you asked if that was important.
My opinion on this topic is, since on this board there are not too many people from Taiwan, nobody cares to celebrate 10/10. By no means I implied 10/10 had no historical importance to China. But not celebrating 10/10 does not mean someone does not care about China's history. Anyway, almost none of China's 1.4 billion population does it.

[fortyNiner]

OK, a not that special "special day", agree?
My first reply is to someone's suggestion of 祝贺 10/10. Anyway, let's see how many on this board will 祝贺 10/10.

Special day 并不是只能 celebrate 的，五四，七七，九一八，一二九年年纪念，你都是 celebrate 的吗？还是你认为它们对中国来说不是 special days？

[A.Blinken]

我们美利坚合众国支持自由中国！反对一党独裁！

[zhangwen720]

版主看来是有资格当汉奸，卖国贼的
这个论坛在中国国庆前被中国给墙了，居然版主还祝这个国家生日快乐。这种热脸凑冷屁股的事只有奴才最喜欢干

[Skl]

版主看来是有资格当汉奸，卖国贼的
这个论坛在中国国庆前被中国给墙了，居然版主还祝这个国家生日快乐。这种热脸凑冷屁股的事只有奴才最喜欢干

庆祝国殇 炖炖炖