粗大了：OpenAI为了IPO造势，不惜剽窃数学家的研究成果

[jg51]

https://www.scientificamerican.com/arti ... -the-same/

OpenAI的辩解

[牛河梁]

诶唉到头了？

[ddmmlls]

好像已经翻转了.数学家其实在抢credit. if the new OpenAI proof is correct, its main theorem is substantially stronger than the result announced by Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge.

Feature	Buckmaster–Alpöge	OpenAI paper
Main equation	3D incompressible Euler	3D incompressible Navier–Stokes
Viscosity	\(\nu=0\)	Every \(\nu>0\)
External force	Smooth	Smooth and compactly supported
Initial velocity	Smooth	Exactly zero
Result	Finite-time blowup	Finite-time blowup with bounded kinetic energy
Millennium Problem	Does not directly resolve it	Claims to establish alternatives C and D

[jg51]

前面tweets里说了，俩数学家almost solved并没完全solve，oAI听到风声集中资源来攻关，用的新思路“凑巧”俩人private prompts的一样，scientificamerican文章里说Buckmaster问oAI的Bubeck用了他俩的private prompts没？"Bubeck told him no but wouldn’t answer whether the model’s training involved user data, which might have included Buckmaster and Alpöge’s private prompts, Buckmaster alleged."

好像已经翻转了.数学家其实在抢credit. if the new OpenAI proof is correct, its main theorem is substantially stronger than the result announced by Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge.

Feature	Buckmaster–Alpöge	OpenAI paper
Main equation	3D incompressible Euler	3D incompressible Navier–Stokes
Viscosity	\(\nu=0\)	Every \(\nu>0\)
External force	Smooth	Smooth and compactly supported
Initial velocity	Smooth	Exactly zero
Result	Finite-time blowup	Finite-time blowup with bounded kinetic energy
Millennium Problem	Does not directly resolve it	Claims to establish alternatives C and D

[牛河梁]

好像已经翻转了.数学家其实在抢credit. if the new OpenAI proof is correct, its main theorem is substantially stronger than the result announced by Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge.

Feature	Buckmaster–Alpöge	OpenAI paper
Main equation	3D incompressible Euler	3D incompressible Navier–Stokes
Viscosity	\(\nu=0\)	Every \(\nu>0\)
External force	Smooth	Smooth and compactly supported
Initial velocity	Smooth	Exactly zero
Result	Finite-time blowup	Finite-time blowup with bounded kinetic energy
Millennium Problem	Does not directly resolve it	Claims to establish alternatives C and D

原创Idea最重要。后面的只是累脖活。

[jg51]