今天最高法院6：3的判决，“会导致”非法移民和F1, J1, B1,H1B在美国出生子女没有公民权

[大漠孤烟]

川普的行政命令：新生儿的父母必须至少有一方是公民或者绿卡，新生儿即可获得美国公民身份。

[datoumao]

四年后民主党上台，发个EO大赦，每个人都拿美国公民。

[shanghaibaba]

这是总统赦免权，不是总统eo。总统eo现在连宪法都能override了，override你个移民法，算什么？

[wyseman]

看新闻看一半就来嚷嚷，说的是地方法院没有nationwide的injection权力，要限制，还给了30天让地方法院裁决
高原根本没有对非公民绿卡小孩是否有公民权这个关键问题裁决，真要打倒高院，估计高院还是要维持14th
现在就是拖时间让地方法院案子审理起来，法官的裁决估计就只能对管辖区和起诉相关人有效
弄不好就是在加州生就是公民，德州生就没有，非法移民全部搬家去兰州，兰州人民有福了

injunction不是injection。

[VladPutin]

梅花的子女可能成为无国籍人士，没法申请绿卡，只能去萨尔瓦多踩缝纫机。

[在路上]

梅花的子女可能成为无国籍人士，没法申请绿卡，只能去萨尔瓦多踩缝纫机。

不至于。可以拿中国旅行证和护照

[Burlingame]

再过四年，MAGA党再上台，一纸EO再给废了

最后eo就是废纸，只有四年有效期

[pathdream]

狂赞狂赞再狂赞

[mmking]

以后川宝的EO只能折腾红州了？

求仁得仁

绿灯的意思是，下级法院没有办法在全国限制总统EO了。

所以今天川普团队欢欣鼓舞。

[fuzzymath]

敌国的F1和H1的子女不能获得美国公民。
中文媒体都故意忽略敌国这个关键字。

[matlab]

就事论事
联邦政府的行政令地方法官可以随意*在全国范围内*喊停，是非常混蛋的，导致整个系统逻辑混乱，纠正这个bug非常必要

是重大胜利不假，今后地方民主党法官不再可以随意在全国范围内阻止总统行政令了, 川普可以放手干了

[noktard]

狂赞
一帮沙茶求仁得仁

[VladPutin]

不至于。可以拿中国旅行证和护照

那要看娃的年龄。

[Xiaofish]

敌国的F1和H1的子女不能获得美国公民。
中文媒体都故意忽略敌国这个关键字。

哪有敌对国家？母亲非法或者临时身份，父亲没绿卡不是公民就不是公民，所有的。

[Unclegao]

川普获得了重大胜利

更新一下标题

个人认为应该不包括H1b

[牛河梁]

哪有敌对国家？母亲非法或者临时身份，父亲没绿卡不是公民就不是公民，所有的。

仅限于解放区群众。广大敌州情绪稳定。

[在路上]

个人认为应该不包括H1b

看这一句：If this order is upheld, children born in the U.S. to parents on H-1B visas would not automatically acquire U.S. citizenship.


Based on recent news reports and official statements, here's what you need to know about a Trump executive order potentially affecting citizenship for those on H-1B visas:

Proposed Action:

President Trump's administration has proposed an executive order, Executive Order 14156, titled "Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship".
This order seeks to end automatic U.S. citizenship for children born in the United States to non-citizen parents, including parents on temporary visas like H-1Bs.
The executive order asserts that the 14th Amendment has been misinterpreted and that citizenship should not extend to those born in the U.S. when their mother is unlawfully present or on a temporary visa, and the father is not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.


Impact on H-1B Holders:

If this order is upheld, children born in the U.S. to parents on H-1B visas would not automatically acquire U.S. citizenship.
This could have significant implications for H-1B families, potentially requiring children to apply for dependent visas and facing the risk of losing their immigration status at age 21.
It could also create legal uncertainties and impact aspects like higher education for these children.

[Xiaofish]

个人认为应该不包括H1b

eo原文包括work visa，H1b恐怕包括

[Unclegao]

看这一句：If this order is upheld, children born in the U.S. to parents on H-1B visas would not automatically acquire U.S. citizenship.


Based on recent news reports and official statements, here's what you need to know about a Trump executive order potentially affecting citizenship for those on H-1B visas:

Proposed Action:

President Trump's administration has proposed an executive order, Executive Order 14156, titled "Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship".
This order seeks to end automatic U.S. citizenship for children born in the United States to non-citizen parents, including parents on temporary visas like H-1Bs.
The executive order asserts that the 14th Amendment has been misinterpreted and that citizenship should not extend to those born in the U.S. when their mother is unlawfully present or on a temporary visa, and the father is not a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.


Impact on H-1B Holders:

If this order is upheld, children born in the U.S. to parents on H-1B visas would not automatically acquire U.S. citizenship.
This could have significant implications for H-1B families, potentially requiring children to apply for dependent visas and facing the risk of losing their immigration status at age 21.
It could also create legal uncertainties and impact aspects like higher education for these children.

EO原文是visit 的work visa。显然H1b的性质是resident而不是visit。再说老船说过要给在美国拿到学位的外国人自动绿卡，所以我乐观估计以后对F1的影响会很小。

[hh2025]

感觉以后民主党当选的几率越来越低